I want to wish everyone a wonderful festive season, however (and if) you celebrate! This has been a challenging year for the Pickings family, and I feel that this has been the case for many. So once again, I want to say thanks for being here, take care, and "see you" all in the New Year. OMG: 2026!! How is that even possible? :=)
Makes 8 (or more):
ingredients:
2 Tbs EV olive oil
4 brown onions, cut into 16 thick rounds
500g./1.1 lb starchy potatoes, peeled and sliced thinly
160 mL/5.5 oz chicken or vegetable stock
80g./2.8 oz butter, melted
8 sprigs thyme
sea salt flakes, and freshly-ground black pepper
parsley or chives, for serving
Method:
Turn on your oven to 180C/350F, to heat up
Grab a muffin tin, and line 8 of the holes with baking paper (or patty pan liners) see Notes
Into your large (non-stick) frying pan, pour in the olive oil, and let it get nicely heated
And in go the onion slices, (in batches if need be); let 'em cook for 3 minutes or so, turning once, till golden (let them cool for a few) then
Plop one onion slice into the bottom of each muffin hole
Divvy up the potato slices into the holes, and then throw on the rest of the onion slices into each muffin hole
Now the stock and butter gets divvied up into each hole, then you whack a thyme sprig on top of each one
Cover with aluminium foil, and roast away for 30 minutes
Now uncover and roast for another 30 minutes, till beautifully tender and golden
Plate them, and season well with the salt and pepper, and some parsley or chives if you like
Serve with a protein, or anything you fancy (we had ours with a salad)
Notes:
Notes? Notes? Nah, no notes here :=) Hang on, I do have a note (or 2) - I sprinkled some smoked sea salt flakes over the onion slices when frying them up!
I would strongly suggest using patty pan/muffin tin liners rather than baking paper. Donna does not tell you how on earth you would manage to get baking paper into the holes, without it flying everywhere!!
And another: try frying up the onion slices for a bit longer than 3 minutes per side - I did it for about 5 minutes before turning over, and frying for another 5!
I somehow ended up with a lot of onion and potato slices, so I ended up making 12 delightful stacks. Well, you can't be sad about that, can you?
To be honest, this was a wee bit of faffing; but I reckon you could make these the day before (sans the melted butter and stock), let 'em sit in the fridge, then add the butter and stock, and bake till golden and scenting your kitchen with onion-y wafts. And another thought - why melt the butter first? Just throw on a big knob, on top of each one ...
These are seriously delicious, my friends! And no wonder, with all that oil and butter and salt ...
![]() |
| ingredients gathered (am I Harry Potter? hehehehe) |
![]() |
| fry up those onion slices in delicious EV olive oil |
![]() |
| layer your onion and potato slices |
![]() |
| throw on some thyme sprigs |
For those readers who asked about Mr P. - yes, he has had his preliminary procedure in hospital and is doing well. Thanks for asking!
(Joining in with Jo from Brookford Kitchen Diaries, for the monthly link-up BKD Cookbook Club. Happy Christmas to all!)

.jpg)



.jpg)
.jpg)



Potatoes, butter, onions... what could possibly be wrong with that? Thank you for your support this year... I look forward to more kitchen antics in 2026.
ReplyDeleteyep delicious for sure! Cheers and merry xmas.
DeleteThese look great
ReplyDeletethanks!
DeleteGlad Mr. P is doing well. I think imwld make one huge bowl of these rather. Hope next year is way better!
ReplyDeleteTandy (Lavender and Lime) https://tandysinclair.com
thank you. Yes that could be a good idea to make one big dish!
DeleteMust have smelled heavenly!
ReplyDeleteit did indeed Angie. Happy festives.
DeleteI have to try these two of my favourite vegetables! And these would be wonderful for entertaining!
ReplyDeleteMatty @ Matty Somewhere | https://mattysomewhere.com/
thanks Matty. We enjoyed them!
DeleteSherry- I love this recipe. I might even try it for Chanukah instead of making fried potato pancakes. Thanks for the recipe and step by step photos.
ReplyDeleteexcellent! it was pretty delish!
DeleteHang in there, Mrs. P - we're all with you. And that's great news about Mr. P! As far as the recipe, this sounds like a fantastic holiday side dish. Roasted potatoes and caramelized onions pair so well together. Happy Holidays, my friend!
ReplyDeletethanks David. Yep onions and potatoes are terrific together. Happy festive season to you.
DeleteWonderful idea! I love the combination!
ReplyDeletethanks Marie.
DeleteYes!Yes!Yes! - Perfect for entertaining :)
ReplyDeleteso true Judi. merry xmas!
DeleteThis looks wonderful
ReplyDeletethanks Anne.
DeleteYum, this would be a great part of a christmas roast. I would love to try it but every time I try and cook slices of potato in the oven they never cook through - maybe it is my oven! (And good to hear Mr P is making good progress)
ReplyDeletethese cook well due to the butter and stock! the potato slices were delectable.
DeleteFingers crossed for continued healing and good health. These look so good! I need to get that book.
ReplyDeleteHTTP://www.chefmimiblog.com
yes it's a good book. happy festives!
DeleteThese look incredible. (But then, you had me at caramelized onions!)
ReplyDeletethanks Jeanie.
DeleteYes please, caramelized onions and crispy potatoes sound terrific. I happy to know that Mr. P is doing well. Here is to a better year for us both.
ReplyDeleteyes indeed Happy festives to you and yours and here's to a fab 2026!
DeleteForgot to say that it is Karen (Back Road Journal)
ReplyDeletehi Karen!
DeleteI hope 2026 is so much better for you and your family. Also - I love potato stacks but haven't ever had potato and onion stacks and now I need this in my life. Thanks so much for this recipe!
ReplyDeletethank you Shashi! merry festives to you.
DeleteI'm glad that Mr P is doing well and I hope that 2026 is a great year for you. These look delicious! :)
ReplyDeletethank you Lorraine.
DeleteSending good thoughts and prayers for Mr. P and for the good resolution of all the issues your family faces. This looks delicious!
ReplyDeletethank you Deb. Very kind. happy festives to you.
DeleteI saw these on your instagram and they had me drooling! And I'm with you on the patty cases. Thank you for all your support this year and I hope that 2026 brings Team Pickings an abundance of good health and good fortune. See you on the other side xx
ReplyDeletethey are good Sammie. Happy festive season to you and Dave and all your loved ones!
DeleteOooh yum. These look great. Thanks for sharing.
ReplyDeletethank you Hena. Happy happy festives to you.
DeleteWhat an interesting way to cook these, they look absolutely delicious. Donna Hay is such an icon, I have my eye on so many books for Christmas. Good luck with receiving the cookbook you want.
ReplyDeletethanks Pauline. I'm pretty sure i will get that book from hubby :)
DeleteLike you, I love Donna Hay — I have quite a few of her books! This recipe does sound seriously delicious, Sherry! Thanks! ~ David (C&L)
ReplyDeleteThanks David.
DeleteSherry! I love how simple the ingredients are but how fancy the final result turns out
ReplyDeletethank you Raymund. Merry christmas to you.
Delete