I love mushrooms (who knew some folk don't feel the same?), so this recipe from The Irish Countrywomen's Association Cookbook was calling my name. I used to make a similar dish which is a mushroom and paprika soup, also an Irish recipe. Maybe there's foraging to be done in those Irish landscapes :=) - but grab yourself a mycology handbook first!
Well, now you know I'm going to have to mention The Mushroom Killer! There is a murder trial going on at present, where a Victorian woman has been charged with poisoning four relatives (three died) with a Beef Wellington dish (recipe from Nagi/Recipe Tin Eats can you believe?). There's so much circumstantial evidence pointing to her guilt, but we will have to wait to see what the jury thinks.
But you definitely won't get ill when you eat this delicious 'shroomy dish, my friends. It's vegetarian, of course, but I added some chicken to pump up the protein factor. Maybe add some marinated tofu steaks instead ...
![]() |
butter makes everything better :=) |
Serves 4:
ingredients:
450g.-500g./16-18 oz mushrooms, chopped into quarters see Notes
2-3 Tbs olive oil
50g./1.8 oz butter (more or less, as you see fit)
2-3 Tbs brandy, sherry, vodka (optional) - a splash of water if needed
1 large red or brown onion, finely chopped
1 Tbs sweet paprika
1-2 tsp dried garlic granules (optional)
250 mL/8.5 oz stock (chicken/veg./whatever)
150-200 mL (5-7 oz) crème fraîche or double cream
sea salt and freshly-ground black pepper
a handful of parsley (or chives, or dried oregano), chopped
To serve:
Brown rice (I get Mr P. to cook up the rice, as he has the knack)
![]() |
mushies |
red onions |
Method:
Once you've chopped the mushrooms, add half the olive oil and butter to a large frying pan
Tip the mushies into the heated oil/butter mixture, and cook over a high heat for a good 5 minutes or more till tender (stirring frequently)
Add the brandy, etc (or water), and stir in well for a minute or two
Then spoon them into a dish, and put aside while you make the sauce
Turn down the heat to medium, and add the rest of the olive oil and butter to the same frying pan
Now fry up your chopped onion till nicely golden and smelling oh-so-good (I'll have to air the house out again)
Stir in the paprika and garlic granules for 30 seconds, and add the stock
Let it come to a boil, and reduce it by a third
Stir in the crème fraîche, and simmer for a couple of minutes
Spoon the mushrooms back into the creamy sauce
Season with salt and pepper
Serve up on brown rice, and strew chopped parsley over the top
Add some marinated chicken or tofu to the plate, if you are inclined
![]() |
parsley |
Notes:
Use whichever mushrooms you fancy, or a mix, and chop into quarters or whatever size you like (depends on the size of your mushroom too)
Can be served with chicken tenderloins or breast fillets, marinated in olive oil, herbs and seasoning for about 20 minutes, then baked or grilled till cooked thru
(Thanks to Norah McDermott of Kildare, who supplied this recipe to the ICA)
![]() |
smiley mushies |
![]() |
gather your ingredients (darn, I bought the wrong parsley!) |
![]() |
marinate your chicken or tofu |
![]() |
yep, delicious butter about to sizzle |
![]() |
put aside while you make the sauce |
![]() |
smelling delicious! |
![]() |
about to stir it all together |
![]() |
throw on your herbs! |
![]() |
I'm ready to eat! |
(Joining in with Jo from BKD Cookbook Club; this month's theme is Comfort.)
![]() |
cheeky little 'shroom |
Well, I am one of those people who don't even like mushrooms! But I love the murder trial where mushrooms were the weapon. One of our houses had a big woods and so many loved the puff balls? that grew there - non-poisonous :)
ReplyDeletereally? Oh I love 'em :) Yes the verdict will be interesting on that trial.
DeleteOK, I’m going to make a version of this right now. Seriously!
ReplyDeleteExcellent Mae. I got your photo via email! Hope you liked it.
DeleteI too love mushrooms because my stomach can handle them good, if I didn't eat more than 250 grams at one set...
ReplyDeleteyes they are a fave of mine. I love the taste and the texture!
DeleteI love mushrooms - this looks good.
ReplyDeletethanks Barbara.
DeleteI have always loved mushrooms, even as a kid. I was gifted a recipe when I was a vegetarian in my 20s — I still make it to this day. I’ll need to see how yours differs! David (C&L)
ReplyDeletethere are lots of good mushie recipes around!
DeleteLooks so good. I will try it!
ReplyDeleteExcellent Marie.
DeleteI love mushrooms and have even been foraging. But with an expert as I have no clue what's safe. I'm sure the Aussie woman intended harm!
ReplyDeleteyes gotta be careful!
DeleteEha saying 'hello' anonymously as I just have not been able to get thru'! The Victorian story is painful - too many coincidences for the lady to be 100% innocent, but . . . ! So many lives permanently ruined!!! You have a beautiful recipe here - I love mushrooms and, of course, they are part of the original recipe. Brandy and sour cream and no garlic for me - but, did I tell you I was taught the VERY ORIGINAL recipe by my grandmother who was a close friend of Count Stroganoff in St Petersburg in the 1890s and stood in the kitchen to watch his French chef make it and wrote it down! Am not lying :) !
ReplyDeletehi Eha. Sorry about that. Ooh your story sounds fascinating to say the least - how marvellous!
DeleteWe love a good stroganoff, or really any mushrooms. Or at least 2 out of 3 of us in this house do. The other one just has to put up with them! lol
ReplyDeletesounds fair :) Mushies are marvellous!
DeleteI love mushrooms, and the flavours of a beef stroganoff so I'm pretty keen to give this a try. Oh to have access to field mushroons but I don't know enough about them. Always anon when commenting on the phone. Pauline (Happy Retirees Kitchen)
ReplyDeleteBlogger is so annoying when it comes to commenting!
DeleteI love a good stroganoff and mushrooms so I will be trying this recipe. It looks so good.
ReplyDeletethanks Lori.
DeleteI love mushrooms done any way and so this would be right up my alley. I appreciate your step out photos! The Mushroom Trial sounds very interesting. Don't forget to share the verdict!
ReplyDeletethanks Jeanie. Yep i will keep readers abreast of the mushroom killer verdict :)
DeleteI love all things mushroom and cook something similar to go on toast or with noodles nom nom
ReplyDeletesounds very delicious!
DeleteYum.. that looks so good.
ReplyDeletethanks Hena.
DeleteOh yum! This sounds like a winner. And we should be finding some Chicken of the Woods mushrooms in the wild soon!
ReplyDeletethanks granny sue. Be careful with that foraging :=)
DeleteI love mushrooms and even enjoy some varieties raw. This is a great and hearty twist on an old good classic recipe, and I'd be even better with some wild mushrooms.
ReplyDeletewild mushrooms? Brave of you! Foraging you mean?
DeleteI love mushrooms and even enjoy some varieties raw. This is a great and hearty twist on an old good classic recipe, and I'd be even better with some wild mushrooms.
ReplyDeletethanks again Ben.
Deleteummm... YUM!!!!! I'm a massive fan of a strog...
ReplyDeleteme too! well, a vego version anyway.
DeleteThanks for linking up.
ReplyDeleteno worries!
DeleteI heard about that mushroom killer trial - crazy stuff! And I didn't realize it was a recipe from Nagi that was used. That's gotta feel strange for her. Anyhoo, I'm still hit-or-miss on mushrooms. But stroganoff is an all-time classic in the world of comfort food, so I might just need to give this one a try!
ReplyDeleteyes weird indeed! Oh no you don't like mushies David? They are so good.
DeleteSherry, I know we share opposite seasons but, I could enjoy your hearty mushroom soup all year round. I may have to stick to the farmers market for my mushrooms ;-)
ReplyDeleteyep i agree - mushrooms are great all year round.
DeleteBig fan of mushroom stroganoff here too, and I totally agree, butter does make everything better!
ReplyDeleteFor sure Raymund.
DeleteI LOVE mushrooms, so I would like this...not sure anyone else would in my family. The mushroom trial...at first I wondered if this was a cozy mystery book. haha! Great choice for comfort.
ReplyDeletedefinitely not a book but a real trial. Verdict in soon.
DeleteThis looks delicious! I will make this and report back!
ReplyDeleteexcellent John.
DeleteIt looks so tempting, and I love the texture.
ReplyDeleteLinda :)
thanks Linda.
DeleteI actually didn't like mushrooms when I was a kid, but later in life I realized I just hadn't had them well made. Now I love them—and especially in creamy sauces like this one.
ReplyDeleteyes i can see why you may not have liked them if not cooked well. I think i have always been a fan tho.
DeleteWell this recipe is very on point - what with the trial and all that! i absolutely adore mushrooms. Funny story, when I first met David I made him this pasta sauce loaded with mushrooms and I found out weeks later that he hated mushrooms, LOL! i'm pleased to report I turned him and he's now a mushroom fan - this dish would go down a treat at our house!
ReplyDeleteoh yes this trial has been a bit of a cliff-hanger really. Seems like a movie plot. I am a definite mushie fan but i can see why people would not be :)
Delete